German “Comfort Women” POWs Were Shocked When American Soldiers Didn’t Even Touch Them
April 1945, Bavaria. The Vermacht had fled, leaving behind their darkest secret, a military brothel where German women had been trapped for years. When American tanks rolled through the smoke, 23-year-old Greta Weber instinctively stepped in front of the younger girls, the same protective stance she’d held since she was 19.

These women had learned that liberation by enemy soldiers meant one thing. continued nightmare under new masters. But as the dust settled and American soldiers approached, something impossible happened. Instead of grabbing and dividing them, the soldiers handed them blankets. Clean blankets that smelled of soap, not sweat and fear. When Sergeant Morrison posted rules in German on their barracks wall, including no prisoner will be sexually assaulted or harmed, they were certain it was cruel mockery.
But day after day, no one touched them without permission. No one entered their quarters uninvited. These weren’t the monsters they’d been taught to fear. These were men who somehow still saw them as human beings worth protecting. But how do you learn to trust again when trust itself feels like betrayal?
The thunder arrived first, a deep rumble that seemed to rise from the earth itself, growing stronger until the floorboards beneath their feet began to vibrate.
Greta Weber pressed her back against the wooden wall of the barracks and instinctively stepped sideways, positioning herself between the approaching sound, and the two younger women huddled on the narrow CS behind her. At 23, she had learned that protection meant making yourself the first target, the most visible shield. “American tanks!” whispered Leisel, her 19-year-old voice barely audible above the mechanical roar growing closer. Her hands twisted the thin fabric of her dress.
a nervous habit that had worn permanent creases into the gray cotton over the past three years. Ingred Schneider sat rigidly upright on her cot, her 28-year-old frame maintaining the perfect posture of the school teacher she had once been. They’re coming through the main road, she said with clinical precision, though her knuckles were white where she gripped the edge of her blanket. The Vermach pulled out before dawn, left everything behind, everything, including them.
The barracks fell silent except for their shallow breathing and the growing thunder outside. Through the single grimy window, Greta could see dust clouds rising in the distance, backlit by the pale April Sunday. She had been in this room for 4 years since the soldiers had come to her village when she was 19 and told her family she was needed for essential war work. The lie had been so clean, so official.
Her mother had even packed her a small bag with her best dress and her grandmother’s prayer book. The prayer book was long gone now, traded for an extra piece of bread during the terrible winter of 1943. But Greta still remembered every word of the prayers her grandmother had taught her, even if she could no longer bring herself to speak them. The mechanical rumbling grew deafening, then suddenly stopped.
In the silence that followed, Greta could hear male voices shouting in English, sharp authoritative commands she couldn’t understand but recognized as the language of conquest. She had heard German officers give similar orders when they arrived at new postings, that tone of men taking control of territory. “Stay behind me,” she whispered, though she knew it was pointless. There was nowhere to run, nowhere to hide.
The barracks had no back door, no escape route. They had learned not to look for such things anyway. Heavy boots crunched across gravel outside, growing closer. Multiple sets of them, moving with military precision. Greta felt her body automatically assumed the position that had kept her alive for 4 years, shoulders back, eyes down, hands clasped loosely at her sides, available but not eager, compliant but not broken.
It was a careful balance that had taken months to master. Leisel made a small whimpering sound and pressed herself against the far wall. She had been 16 when they brought her from the Hamburg orphanage, told she was being sent to work in a factory. The youngest of them, she had never quite learned to hide her fear the way the others had. Her terror was too honest, too visible.
“Breathe,” Ingred murmured, her teacher’s instincts still intact despite everything. “Just breathe.” The boots stopped directly outside their door. A man’s voice spoke in English. Then another answered. Greta caught the word secure and understood enough to know they were discussing the building, the contents, the inventory.
She had become fluent in the language of being counted and cataloged. The door handle turned with a slow squeak of rusted metal. Greta straightened her spine and lifted her chin slightly, not defiant, but present, visible. She had learned that it was better to be seen immediately than to be discovered hiding.
Men who found you hiding assumed you had something to be ashamed of, something to punish. Sunlight flooded the dim barracks as the door swung open, silhouetting a tall figure in an American uniform. Behind him, she could see more soldiers, younger men with clean shaven faces, and pressed khaki that smelled of soap and starch instead of sweat and cigarettes. The officer in the doorway paused, taking in the scene before him.
His eyes moved from Greta to Lisel to Ingred, and she saw something flicker across his features that she hadn’t seen in a man’s face for 4 years. Something that looked almost like shock, then recognition, then something else entirely. Something that might have been pity if she had dared to hope for such a thing. He spoke quietly to the soldiers behind him, then stepped back without entering their space.
We’re not going to hurt you, he said in careful, accented German. You’re safe now. The words hung in the air like smoke. Impossible to believe, yet impossible to ignore. Greta felt something shift in her chest. A tiny crack in the wall she had built around her expectations. She had learned not to trust promises from men and uniforms. But this man hadn’t even crossed their threshold.
The truck bed was lined with clean canvas that didn’t smell of diesel or unwashed bodies. Greta sat pressed between Leisel and Ingrid, their shoulders touching, a formation they had maintained through countless transports over the years. But this time, no one had separated them.
No one had pointed at Leisel and dragged her to a different vehicle or shoved Ingred toward the officer’s transport. They were together and that small mercy felt so unexpected that Greta almost couldn’t process it. The American soldier driving the truck had helped them climb up without touching them unnecessarily.
He had simply extended his hand palm up, waiting for them to decide whether to accept the assistance. When Leisel had flinched away from the offered help, he had quietly placed a wooden crate beside the tailgate for her to use as a step instead. Through the canvas opening, Greta watched the Bavarian countryside roll past, fields scarred by tank treads and abandoned equipment, but still green with spring growth. The war was ending.
Everyone said so. She had heard it whispered among the guards in their final days, seen it in the way the Vermached officers had destroyed documents and fled before dawn. But endings had never meant freedom for women like them. Endings just meant new beginnings under different masters. Camp Lucky Strike sprawled across a hillside like a temporary city.
Rows of canvas tents and wooden buildings stretched in neat military lines surrounded by wire fences that looked disturbingly familiar. Greta felt her stomach tighten as they approached the main gate. The guards there wore different uniforms and spoke different words, but gates were gates and fences were fences. The truck stopped in front of a low wooden building marked with a red cross symbol.
The same soldier who had driven them opened the tailgate and stepped back, giving them space to climb down on their own. Greta noticed how he kept his hands visible, how he announced each movement before making it. These were not the behaviors of men who took what they wanted without asking.
A tall sergeant emerged from the building, his uniform crisp despite the late afternoon heat. His face was weathered but kind with crows feet that suggested he smiled more often than he frowned. He spoke to the driver in English, then approached them with careful, measured steps. “My name is Sergeant Morrison,” he said in heavily accented but clear German.
“You will be staying in building 7. It is clean and secure. No one will enter without your permission.” Leisel made a small sound of disbelief, quickly muffled, “Permission?” The word felt foreign, almost meaningless. They had not been asked permission for anything in so long that Greta had forgotten what it felt like to have choices that mattered.
Morrison led them across the compound, past rows of tents where American soldiers looked up from their evening activities. Some stared with curious eyes, others with expressions Greta couldn’t read. But none of them called out crude suggestions or made the gestures she had learned to expect. They simply watched and returned to their card games and letterw writing.
Building seven was a converted barracks with six cotss arranged along the walls, each with a folded blanket and a small wooden crate that served as a bedside table. The blankets were wool, thick and clean, with the kind of softness that spoke of proper washing and care. Greta ran her fingers along the edge of one and felt something loosen in her chest at the simple luxury of clean fabric.
There are rules, Morrison said, pulling a sheet of paper from his jacket pocket. He tacked it to the wall beside the door, the German text written in careful block letters. Rule number one, no prisoner will be sexually assaulted or harmed. Rule number two, no soldier may enter this building without permission from the occupants.
Rule number three, meals will be delivered at 0800, 1200, and 1,800 hours. You are not required to earn them. Ingrid stared at the posted rules with the intensity of someone trying to decode a foreign language. This is, she began, then stopped as if the words she needed didn’t exist in any language she knew. A young guard appeared in the doorway carrying a metal pot and three bowls.
He was barely older than Leisel with the soft face of someone who had probably been working on his family’s farm a year ago. He set the pot on the floor just inside the door and stepped back immediately. Soup, he said in broken German, his cheeks flushing pink with effort. Hot soup for eating.
When he reached toward Leisel to hand her a bowl directly, she flinched so violently that she stumbled backward and fell onto one of the CS. The young guard froze, his face going pale with horror at having frightened her. Morrison appeared beside him instantly. Johnson, he said quietly in English, then switched to German. We announce ourselves. We keep distance. We let them come to us. The guard Johnson nodded rapidly and set the bowls on the floor beside the pot.
Sorry, he whispered in German. Very sorry. No hurt. No hurt. After they left, the three women sat in silence, staring at the steaming pot of soup. It smelled of vegetables and meat, rich and nourishing. But more than that, it had been given freely, without demands or expectations.
Greta reached for a bowl with trembling fingers, half expecting someone to appear and name the price she would have to pay for this kindness. No one came. Outside their window, she could hear American soldiers calling to each other in the gathering dusk, their voices carrying the easy camaraderie of men who slept safely at night.
For the first time in 4 years, Greta allowed herself to wonder if she might sleep safely, too. The routine began to feel like a small miracle by the third day. Breakfast arrived at 8:00 precisely, delivered by the young soldier Johnson, who had learned to knock twice, announce himself, and wait for permission before entering.
He set the tray just inside the door with careful reverence, as if he understood he was handling something more fragile than dishes and food. Greta found herself waking before the knock each morning, her body still programmed for hypervigilance, but no longer braced for immediate threat.
She would lie on her cot, listening to Leisel’s soft breathing and Ingred’s precisely controlled sleep, marveling at the absence of heavy boots in the hallway, the lack of crude voices demanding entrance. The silence felt almost too good to trust. The infection in her shoulder had been festering for weeks, a souvenir from a particularly brutal vermocked officer who had enjoyed leaving marks.
She had hidden it well, knowing that visible wounds often made men either more violent or more disgusted. But on the fourth morning, when she couldn’t lift her right arm without wincing, Leisel noticed the way she favored her left side. “You’re hurt,” Leisel said, her voice carrying the particular gentleness she reserved for moments when she wasn’t drowning in her own terror. “The shoulder?” “Yes.
” Before Greta could deflect or minimize, Ingred was beside her with the efficient assessment of someone who had spent years caring for others. “That needs medical attention,” she said with quiet authority. “It’s infected.” The idea of voluntarily asking for help from American soldiers felt impossible.
“Help had always come with a price, and medical attention from men had never been about healing. But as the morning wore on, and the throbbing in her shoulder worsened, Greta found herself considering the unthinkable. When Johnson arrived with lunch, Ingred stepped forward with the careful dignity that made her seem taller than her actual height.
“Excuse me,” she said in her precise German, then attempted the English phrase she had been practicing. “Medical help, please.” Johnson’s boyish face immediately creased with concern. He set down the food tray and hurried away, returning minutes later with a compact Asian-American soldier who moved with the quiet efficiency of someone accustomed to emergencies.
“I’m Corporal Chin,” the medic said in German. “That was significantly better than Morrison’s. I understand someone needs medical attention.” When Greta reluctantly indicated her shoulder, Chen nodded and opened his medical bag on the small table.
But instead of immediately reaching for her, he began pulling out supplies and explaining each item as he set it down. Antiseptic solution for cleaning, he said, showing her a brown bottle, clean bandages, antibiotic powder. This might sting when I clean the wound, but it will help prevent further infection. He paused and looked directly at her. I need to examine the injury to treat it properly.
Is that acceptable to you? The question hung in the air like something unprecedented, acceptable to you, as if her acceptance mattered, as if she had the right to say no to a man who wanted to touch her. “Yes,” she whispered, then cleared her throat and said it again more firmly. “Yes.” Chen’s examination was clinical and gentle, his hands careful and his voice steady as he explained each step.
“The infection is localized, but significant. I’ll need to clean it thoroughly and apply antibiotics. You should keep it dry and covered for several days. As he worked cleaning the wound with methodical precision, Greta found herself studying his face. There was no hunger in his expression, no calculation about what this medical attention might entitle him to later.
He simply tended to her injury with the same focused care she imagined he would give to any wounded soldier. There,” he said, finally, securing the clean bandage with medical tape. “Change the dressing daily. If you see red streaks extending from the wound, or if fever develops, have someone find me immediately.” He packed up his supplies and stood, but made no move to leave immediately.
“The human body has remarkable healing capacity when given proper care and safety,” he said quietly. “Both are available to you here.” After he left, the three women sat in stunned silence. Finally, Leisel spoke up with something that might have been wonder. He asked permission before touching you, and he explained everything,” Ingred added, her teacher’s mind cataloging the unprecedented experience, every step, every supply, every reason.
That evening, when Morrison made his routine check, Ingred surprised herself by stepping forward. The Red Cross, she said carefully. Do they carry letters to find family? Morrison’s weathered face softened. Yes, they do. Do you have family you’d like to locate? My sons, Ingred said, and the words seemed to unlock something that had been held tightly closed for years. Twin boys. They would be 11 now.
They were placed in American custody when I was. She stopped, unable to finish the sentence. I’ll get you the paperwork tomorrow, Morrison said gently. The Red Cross has been very effective at reuniting families. That night, for the first time since they had arrived, the three women talked about something other than survival.
Leisel mentioned that she had once wanted to be a teacher like Ingred. Greta spoke haltingly about her mother’s garden, how the roses climbed the cottage walls each summer. Ingred described her son’s laughter, the way they had run to greet her each day after school. Their voices grew stronger as they spoke, losing the whispered quality that had become second nature.
Outside their window, the American camp settled into its evening routine, the sounds of safety and normaly drifting through the spring air. For the first time in years, tomorrow felt like something to anticipate rather than endure. The film reel arrived on a gray morning when the spring air carried more chill than warmth.
Greta noticed the change in the camp’s atmosphere before she understood its source. Conversation stopped abruptly when soldiers passed their building, and the easy laughter that had become familiar background noise grew sparse and strained. Morrison appeared at their door just after breakfast, his usually steady demeanor replaced by something heavier.
Behind him stood a soldier Greta hadn’t seen before. A compact man with hard eyes and shoulders that seemed to carry invisible weight. “This is Corporal Sullivan,” Morrison said in his careful German. “He’ll be working with our unit for the next few weeks.
” Sullivan’s gaze swept over the three women with an expression Greta recognized from years of reading men’s faces for signs of danger. “It wasn’t the clinical assessment of the medic chin, or the gentle concern of young Johnson. This was evaluation, judgment, the look of someone trying to determine guilt or innocence. “Ma’am,” Sullivan said stiffly, nodding toward Ingred as the eldest. But his voice carried an undertone that made Leisel unconsciously step closer to Greta.
After they left, an uncomfortable silence settled over building 7. The easy routine they had begun to trust felt suddenly fragile, as if a single suspicious look could shatter the safety they had barely begun to accept. The change became more pronounced over the following days. Guards, who had grown accustomed to casual conversation, now maintained professional distance.
Johnson still delivered their meals with careful courtesy, but his boyish smile seemed forced, and he avoided meeting their eyes directly. It was Corporal Chin who finally explained what was happening. He arrived to check Greta’s healing shoulder with his usual medical bag, but his typically calm demeanor seemed strained.
“There has been new information about the concentration camps,” he said quietly as he examined her wound. “Film footage, documentation. The soldiers are processing what they’ve seen.” Greta felt her chest tighten. They had heard whispers about the camps over the years, terrible rumors that seemed too horrific to believe. But whispers and documented reality were different things entirely.
“Some of the men are struggling to understand the difference between victims and perpetrators,” Chen continued, applying fresh bandages with gentle precision. “It’s difficult for them to process that German women could suffer under the same system that committed such atrocities.” That afternoon, Sullivan appeared at their door again, but this time without Morrison’s moderating presence.
He carried a manila folder and wore the expression of someone fulfilling an unpleasant duty. “I need to ask you some questions,” he said in heavily accented German, his tone suggesting the questions were more like accusations waiting to be confirmed.
Ingred straightened to her full height, assuming the authoritative posture that had once commanded classrooms. What kind of questions? Sullivan opened the folder and pulled out several photographs. Grainy black and white images that made Lisel gasp and turn away. The images showed emaciated figures behind barbed wire, mass graves, children with hollow eyes.
What did you know? Sullivan asked, his voice tight with barely controlled anger. What did you see? The photographs lay between them like accusations. Greta stared at the evidence of systematic murder and felt something collapse inside her chest. Not surprise, but a terrible confirmation of humanity’s capacity for evil.
She had known evil intimately, had lived with it pressed against her skin for 4 years. But seeing it documented, made official somehow made her own survival feel like complicity. “We knew we were nothing,” she whispered, her voice barely audible. “We knew we didn’t matter. That’s not an answer, Sullivan pressed. And now his anger was fully visible. These camps were all over Germany. People had to know. People had to see.
Leisel began to shake, her fragile stability crumbling under the weight of Sullivan’s accusation. They told us we were lucky, she said, tears streaming down her face. They told us we could have been sent to work camps instead. We thought we thought they meant factory work.
Ingred’s teacher instincts kicked in, even as her own composure threatened to break. We were told we were serving the right, she said with bitter precision. We were told our sacrifice kept worse things from happening to other women. We believed we were the price paid to protect others. Sullivan stared at them with disgust that felt like a physical blow.
How do we know you’re not just as guilty as the rest of them? The question hung in the air like a verdict. Greta felt years of carefully constructed survival crumble around her. The shame she had fought so hard to contain came flooding back, mixed now with the terrible knowledge that while they had been trapped in their own hell, others had suffered and died in ways that made their own torture seem almost merciful by comparison.
“Maybe we are,” Greta said finally, the words scraping her throat raw. “Maybe surviving makes us guilty. Maybe we should have died instead. Sullivan gathered up the photographs and stood, leaving them with their shame and the horrible certainty that their brief taste of dignity had been a cruel illusion. They huddled together on the CS as darkness fell.
No longer three women healing, but three conspirators in history’s greatest crime, marked by their survival as surely as if guilt had been tattooed on their foreheads. Outside their window, the American camp continued its evening routines.
But now those sounds felt distant and condemning, as if even the spring air carried judgment against them. The silence in building 7 had weight now pressing down on them like a physical thing. For 3 days after Sullivan’s interrogation, the women barely spoke, moving through their routines like ghosts haunting their own lives. They accepted their meals with downcast eyes and whispered thanks, waiting for the inevitable moment when someone would realize the truth about what they were and take away even these small mercies. Greta found herself cataloging every kindness she had received since arriving at Camp Lucky
Strike, preparing to surrender each one as payment for the crime of surviving when others had not. The clean blankets, the gentle medical care, the simple dignity of being asked for permission, all of it felt stolen now. Luxuries she had no right to claim.
Leisel had retreated into the manic silence that had once been her primary defense mechanism, rocking slightly on her cot and staring at the wall with unseeing eyes. Ingred sat rigid and watchful, her teacher’s mind working frantically to find some logical framework that could make sense of guilt and innocence in a world where both had become meaningless concepts.
When Morrison appeared in their doorway on the fourth morning, flanked by Sullivan and carrying an official looking document, Greta felt her heart sink toward her stomach. This was the moment she had been expecting, the reckoning, the official judgment that would strip away their temporary sanctuary and confirm what Sullivan’s photographs had already proven. That German women who had survived the war were inherently suspect, complicit by virtue of breathing.
But instead of reading charges or demanding confessions, Morrison stepped forward with the same careful gentleness he had shown since their first day. Sullivan stood behind him, his face a mask of conflicted emotions that seemed to war with each other in real time. What happened in those camps, Morrison said quietly, his weathered hand steady on the document. That’s not on you.
What happened to you? That’s not on you either. The words seemed to come from some impossible place where logic and mercy intersected. Greta felt them hit her chest like physical blows, each syllable challenging the guilt she had wrapped around herself like armor. Morrison turned slightly to include Sullivan in his gaze.
These women survived hell. They’re not the enemy. They’re the evidence of what we’ve been fighting against. Sullivan’s face crumpled slightly, as if some internal dam had finally given way. He looked at Greta with eyes that seemed to see her clearly for the first time, not as a representative of German guilt, but as a young woman whose childhood had been stolen and whose innocence had been weaponized against her.
“How old were you?” he asked in halting German, his voice stripped of the accusation that had defined their previous interactions. “When they took you” 19, Greta whispered, the number feeling both ancient and impossibly young. Sullivan closed his eyes briefly, and when he opened them again, something fundamental had shifted.
Jesus, he breathed in English, then struggled with the German words. My sister, she’s 19 now, at home in Ohio. He extended his hand toward Greta, not to take anything from her, but to offer support as she stood. The gesture was small but monumental.
The first time in four years that a man had reached for her with the intention of lifting her up rather than pulling her down. I’m sorry, he said, and his voice cracked slightly on the words. My brother died fighting this system, I thought. I thought anger would honor him somehow, but he would be ashamed of me right now. He would want me to help you, not hurt you more.
Morrison opened the document in his hands. Not charges or condemnation, but Red Cross paperwork and repatriation forms. “We’ve located Ingred’s sons,” he said gently. “They’re safe in American custody in Munich, healthy and asking about their mother every day.” Ingred’s careful composure finally shattered.
She wept not from pain or shame, but from the foreign sensation of hope fulfilled, of maternal love rewarded rather than punished. Leisel reached for her with shaking hands, and for the first time in days, her young face showed something other than terror. “You’ll all be transferred to the repatriation center next week,” Morrison continued. “But I want you to understand something before you go.
” He looked at each of them in turn, his expression carrying the weight of absolute conviction. “Tell people what you saw here. Tell them some of us remembered you were human when the world forgot.” Greta felt something shift inside her chest. Not the cracking of breaking, but the settling of pieces finding their proper places.
She had been 19 when they stole her life, but she was 23 now, and 23 was old enough to choose what to do with whatever life remained. “Tell your families,” she said, her voice growing stronger with each word, that three German women will spend the rest of their lives proving that mercy is stronger than cruelty. Outside their window, the spring afternoon carried the sounds of men preparing for peace rather than war.
And for the first time since liberation, the future felt like something worth walking toward rather than simply enduring.




